Skip to content

Case archive / Case #9

Case #9: The Pruning Shears

The Conservatory, 4×4. The Daily Case for 3 November 2026. Victim: The Night Porter.

Columns A to D run west to east, rows 1 to 4 north to south. Thick lines are walls. Dark squares are blocked; furniture on an open square is a seat.

The clues

  1. The Apprentice was directly south of the orchid case.
  2. The Botanist was in the Orchid Wing.
  3. The Apprentice was in the Cold Frames.
  4. The Conservator was exactly 3 cells from the bonsai stand.
  5. The Botanist's room had no furniture.
  6. The Victim. The Night Porter's final moments were shared only with the killer.

Place every suspect so that each clue holds, with one person per row and per column. The killer is the only suspect in the victim's room. New to this? Read how to solve a case.

The suspects

  • The Night Porter (the victim)

  • The Apprentice

    Learning the hard way.

    Has been forging signatures for months. With permission, she claims.

  • The Botanist

  • The Conservator

Show the solution

Step by step

  1. Clue 4: “The Conservator was exactly 3 cells from the bonsai stand.” That puts the Conservator on D4.
  2. Clue 2: “The Botanist was in the Orchid Wing.” That puts the Botanist on C3.
  3. Clue 1: “The Apprentice was directly south of the orchid case.” That puts the Apprentice on B2. With those rows and columns taken, that leaves the Night Porter on A1.

Everyone is placed and every clue holds. The Night Porter is in The Cold Frames with only the Apprentice, so the Apprentice is the killer.

Today's case

A new 4×4 case every day, free in your browser.

Play the Daily Case

Bigger boards

The app has 703 built-in cases across 23 worlds, on boards up to 14×14.