Case archive / Case #19
Case #19: Still Life with Motive
The Atelier, 4×4. The Daily Case for 13 November 2026. Victim: The Critic.
Columns A to D run west to east, rows 1 to 4 north to south. Thick lines are walls. Dark squares are blocked; furniture on an open square is a seat.
The clues
- No one other than The Janitor was sitting down.
- The Archivist was found in the Landing.
- The Dealer worked in the Print Room.
- The Janitor was the easternmost of all those in the Painting Loft.
- The Dealer was diagonally adjacent to the printing press.
- The Janitor was exactly 3 paces from The Critic.
- Only one person was sitting down across the whole board.
- The Victim. The Critic's final moments were shared only with the killer.
Place every suspect so that each clue holds, with one person per row and per column. The killer is the only suspect in the victim's room. New to this? Read how to solve a case.
The suspects
-
The Janitor
Sees everything.
Cleaned the studio at 3 AM. The appointment was not scheduled.
-
The Dealer
Moves the work.
Authenticated the forgery. Claims it was an honest mistake.
-
The Critic (the victim)
Sharp eye.
Gave a fatal review. Now claims it wasn't meant to be taken literally.
-
The Archivist
Knows every piece.
Found a discrepancy. Filed it. Then unfiled it.
Show the solution
Step by step
- Clue 5: “The Dealer was diagonally adjacent to the printing press.” That puts the Dealer on A2.
- Clue 6: “The Janitor was exactly 3 paces from The Critic.” The Janitor can only be on C1, C3, D1 or D3. The Critic can only be on C1, C3, D1 or D3.
- Clue 1: “No one other than The Janitor was sitting down.” That puts the Janitor on D1. With those rows and columns taken, that leaves the Critic on C3 and the Archivist on B4.
Everyone is placed and every clue holds. The Critic is in the Painting Loft with only the Janitor, so the Janitor is the killer.
Bigger boards
The app has 703 built-in cases across 23 worlds, on boards up to 14×14.