Skip to content

Case archive / Case #18

Case #18: The Keep's Last Defender

The Ashen Keep, 4×4. The Daily Case for 12 November 2026. Victim: The Undead Merchant.

Columns A to D run west to east, rows 1 to 4 north to south. Thick lines are walls. Dark squares are blocked; furniture on an open square is a seat.

The clues

  1. The Herald was directly east of the vine growth.
  2. The Pale Shade was in the Ash Tower.
  3. The Ashen One was alone in the Bonfire Room.
  4. The Pale Shade was exactly 2 cells from the stool.
  5. The Victim. The Undead Merchant's final moments were shared only with the killer.

Place every suspect so that each clue holds, with one person per row and per column. The killer is the only suspect in the victim's room. New to this? Read how to solve a case.

The suspects

  • The Pale Shade

  • The Herald

  • The Undead Merchant (the victim)

  • The Ashen One

Show the solution

Step by step

  1. Clue 4: “The Pale Shade was exactly 2 cells from the stool.” That puts the Pale Shade on A1.
  2. Clue 1: “The Herald was directly east of the vine growth.” That puts the Herald on C2.
  3. Clue 3: “The Ashen One was alone in the Bonfire Room.” That puts the Ashen One on B4. With those rows and columns taken, that leaves the Undead Merchant on D3.

Everyone is placed and every clue holds. The Undead Merchant is in The Kiln with only the Herald, so the Herald is the killer.

Today's case

A new 4×4 case every day, free in your browser.

Play the Daily Case

Bigger boards

The app has 703 built-in cases across 23 worlds, on boards up to 14×14.